Showing posts with label stigma. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stigma. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 February 2016

Stigma, diabetes-shaming and that joke about Bob.

I used to find jokes about diabetes funny; especially that one about Bob.  I liked it because it was sarcastic and witty, and there was no conceivable way anyone would think chocolate could cause diabetes.  That's what was funny about it, no?  My favourite blogs were ones which used humour to talk about life with diabetes, and my family and friends shared in-jokes a-plenty about diabetes and the many foibles living with it brings. But then something changed.  

Sometime around my late twenties people stopped asking "What is diabetes?", when the topic inevitably came up as my paraphernalia appeared, and instead people started to ask me questions about what I did to get it, or tell me they had known someone who got rid of it (chortle).  In my late twenties at University came questions from seemingly intelligent friends about whether or not I knew that my 'foot was going to fall off' from eating a chocolate bar (thank you, Scrubs), and then along came MatthewWright-gate when angry online conversations were held about 'diabetes-triggering 'Easter Eggs. Suddenly it wasn't so funny when I realised that people did believe it and that worse still - the hobby of diabetes-shaming had begun.

This year I will reach 30 years of having lived with type 1 diabetes.  I was diagnosed long before the internet, Sky TV and smart phones came about, and if we wanted to learn anything about diabetes we had to look it up in a giant book warehouse called a library (Google it). Since then with the dawn of the technological era, information can literally arrive at your fingertips with the flick of a button, the ping of a news alert or by the dulcet tones of Siri.  And information equals education, right? Sadly, no.

Jamie Oliver: Anti-Diabetes Warrior
When I was young and diabetes was raised in conversation, my clumsy 11 year-old self would try to give the best definition of what I was living with, hoping it might make sense. I hadn't yet thought of Jeff.  But now that people can easily find photos of the loveable Jamie Oliver standing in front of a coke bottle with the word 'diabetes' blamefully written on the side, or shop for tasteless greetings cards at Sainsbury's where diabetes is once again the butt of a joke, it has become publicly acceptable to use diabetes as a punch line.  With the era of accessible information also came the era of misinformation, and the blaming of people with diabetes for their own condition.  Suddenly everybody's an expert, and diabetes is fair-game for ridicule.

I recently took to Social Media to ask Sainsbury's for a conversation about that diabetes card (and also of course to ask where I can pick up a piece from their emphysema range, or if the do an asthma-specific selection), because the joke just isn't funny any longer - not when people struggle to separate truth from ridiculous humour.  I have been accused of lacking a sense of humour and of needing to lighten up, but here's the thing, if teenagers stop being bullied due to the image that 'diabetes' now has, or people with type 2 stop living with constant stigma as a result of me temporarily shelving my sense of humour and arguing the point, so be it.

The fact is the Sainsburys card isn't even particularly offensive. It's tasteless at worst.  But it insinuates and represents everything which is wrong with the way diabetes is treated both in the media and over coffee-table conversations around the world. We've come such a long way in thirty years.  Technologically we are in the most exciting season of diabetes. We are in the Summer of  advances in medical equipment and hope for a 'cure'.  But when it comes to diabetes-shaming and the way in which diabetes is used as comedy canon-fodder, we are firmly mid-Winter. We have learnt nothing in the last three decades. 

The answer is seven; Bob has seven candy bars.

Monday, 16 December 2013

Type 2 taboo

I've had type 1 diabetes for almost 27 years and by the measure of time alone, I am an expert in it. I have lived each second, minute, hour and day since I was four years old with it. I will proudly posit that I know more than the world's greatest medical experts because when their day in the office is done and they put down their textbooks, journals and award-winning research and head on home, I don't.  I continue to live with it and feel it, each moment.  

That said, I am in the somewhat unique position that as a person who is obese and has struggled immensely with my weight ever since the diabetes diagnosis darkened our door, I have the opportunity to see a glimpse of the world through the eyes of a person with lifestyle-induced type 2.  I know what it's like to be obese;  I have eaten in secret because I worry what people will think of the 'fat girl' in the corner eating a burger; I have hidden myself from my husband's eyes - and touch - because I'm been ashamed of what I've become;  I've opened myself up and confided in you the psychological warfare I go into each day with disordered eating.  

'Stigma' is a word on many a tongue these days.  It is used in a way to suggest those fighting it are spear-heading a new and forward-thinking world.  We are crime-fighters out for a better world. We talk of changing futures, improving lives, turning pages; of poor media reporting and misconceptions; of re-education and using the global community as the step forward.  And yet, all you have to do is tiptoe into many diabetes forums - forums filled with wonderful, open-minded people - to begin to see that stigma is rife in our very own community.  

The language oft-used to talk about type 2s makes me hugely uncomfortable.  Because if I didn't already have type 1, I would most certainly be at risk of type 2.  It is this blame that I find so raw.  As if the guilt society places upon the overweight for not fitting into an acceptable dress size isn't enough, they are forced too to live with the guilt of having 'brought diabetes upon themselves'.  

"I won't have people thinking I brought it on myself".

"I have no sympathy with people who ate themselves into diabetes"

"I didn't deserve this, I didn't do anything to get this."

Of course you didn't.  None of us did.  But can we really sit there and say that someone with T2 as a result of disordered eating 'brought it upon themselves'?  Is it ever that simple?

In exactly the same way that someone without diabetes cannot possibly imagine how it feels to live with it without making wild assumptions, nor can someone without first-hand experience of disordered eating possibly try to imagine how it feels to have deep-seated issues with food.  It is never just a case of fat, lazy slobs eating too much and giving themselves diabetes. To think so, is to be blind to the truth.  People don't sit there and 'give' themselves diabetes; no-one would make that decision.  And if they got it from abusing food, we should be asking the right questions to understand why!

What do they go through every day?  
Why do they eat this way?  
What happened to them?  
Do they have anyone they can talk to?  
Could I help them? 

Only 70% of people with type 2 are overweight.  There are 30% of people 'tarred' with the unhealthy lifestyle brush too, just as people with type 1 are. But the answer is not to distinguish between those who got it from eating too much and those who didn't - the answer is to reach out and ask WHY they live and eat the way they do.

Perhaps I am so focussed on this issue because this week I sat with my dietician and cried as I begged her for help to address my disordered eating.  Perhaps it is because I am tired of seeing people coldly blame people with type 2 for the poor media reporting of diabetes.  Perhaps it is because I understand what it feels like to feel powerless around food.

Either way my feeling is this; people with type 2 diabetes brought on my over-eating or unhealthy lifestyle did not 'bring diabetes on themselves'.  Diabetes is a by-product of a lifestyle they live and no-one has the right to judge, mock, discriminate or wag their finger at anyone with lifestyle-induced type 2, without first walking a mile in their shoes. No-one.

And until we can rule out stigma within our own communities, we can never truly do so to the rest of the world. That journey starts at home. 

What do you think?  How do you feel about the stigma surrounding diabetes?

Thursday, 12 December 2013

World Diabetes Congress 2013: standing up to stigma and starting projects anew.

When I heard that my friend Carrie Hetherington, from Tauranga, New Zealand, was heading to the World Diabetes Congress in Melbourne, I acted sharpish to make sure that she would be the first guest-poster to grace the pages of Insulin Independent.  

Carrie was the first ever person from New Zealand to become a young leader and is known not only for her dedicated campaign to change New Zealand policy of providing only one brand of glucose meter for all, she also recently won the World Diabetes Day essay competition about the future of diabetes in Nigeria. 

Making waves?  You bet.

Carrie kindly put into words what this event, and the sometimes heart-wrenching information she learnt there, mean to her.  Enjoy...



It's very hard to put the experience of a life time into words. How do you express what it feels like to spend 10 days with over 140 people from 73 countries who have diabetes? People your own age, people just like you. Testing, injecting, carb counting, listening, supporting one another, being understood in a way that only other people with diabetes can. Before I left I worried about being the first ever young leader from New Zealand, little did I know I was about to walk away with precious friends, unforgettable memories and a lifelong global family.

I was lucky enough to represent New Zealand at the November 2013 International Diabetes Federation Young Leaders Programme and the World Diabetes Congress in Melbourne, Australia. The first 5 days involved sitting through intense seminars from morning till night, working during lunches and dinners and taking short coffee breaks. We immersed ourselves in diabetes. We should have been exhausted, but we were running on adrenaline and enthusiasm, we absolutely loved every second of our sessions.

In the remaining 5 days we attended our own selected seminars at the World Diabetes Congress. People of all statuses attended lectures together and I found myself chatting to CEOs, the heads of major pharmaceutical companies, even global leading diabetes specialists. These situations would never happen for young leaders outside of the conference, we were all blown away that people of such high regards wanted to learn about our upcoming projects and had seen us walk on the stage during the opening ceremony. Being at the World Congress taught us how to advocate diabetes, how to put our condition on the map, effectively support our own countries and then extend that internationally. We were taught to change the world.

We spent days learning about the incredible research happening at a global level - the artificial pancreas, genetic testing and the latest diabetes management technology. We even had the privilege of hearing from Dr Fran Kaufman, who truly believes there will be a cure in our own lifetime because their trials are getting so close to that final step. However, it was the personal anecdotes that really moved us. Friends we had made during the first few days stood in front of the audience and bravely shared their own experiences. The situations they had faced due to their diabetes left us speechless and emotional. In China you have to fight to be able to get an education because some schools and universities will reject your application if you have diabetes; your partner's parents will likely end a relationship or engagement due to a diagnosis; and some leaders had even been fired from their jobs. In India the same stigma is rife, diabetes will seriously hinder your marriage prospects, education and survival. In other countries it is seen as a spiritual curse and medication is ignored or withheld because removal of the 'curse' is the only solution they see as being necessary. The implications seem endless, and are of course shocking to hear when you live in such a liberal country with support, technology and funding from your government.

Diabetes has the potential to destroy your future in some parts of the world. People live in fear and they hide their diabetes because of the serious impact it will have on their life. How can you create support groups and help people with diabetes when they are unable to reveal their condition in public? How can you save lives in developing countries when there is no money to buy insulin? These are the questions that remained in our minds, the things that need to change.

It is confronting to hear about these global issues when you have the same condition. But it made all the young leaders stronger, more focused and more excited about creating projects to make a positive change. You can imagine that most of the young leaders arrived with the intention of learning how to improve the situation in their own country, and most of us left bursting with extra ideas about changing the rest of the world. Our enthusiasm seemed to excitedly snowball during each day of the conference.

The primary goal behind the Young Leaders Programme is for each attendee to return to their country and successfully implement a project in the next two years, before the Vancouver 2015 conference. This project could be anything from a small support group to a camp, or a large global initiative. So keep your eyes and ears open, because 140 young leaders are about to try and confront world issues, remove stigmas and make the world a better place to live in for people with diabetes. The quote we were left with was by Mahatma Gandi, 'be the change you wish to see in the world'. What can you do to change the world? How can you help people with diabetes in your country?

If you are ambitious, excited and between the ages of 18-30. You could be chosen to represent your country at the Vancouver conference in 2015, and I'll be there talking about my projects too. Please have a look at the IDF website when applications open in 2014 http://youngleaders.idf.org/join and talk to your national member association. Before you apply, see what you can do to help in your region. How can you use your positivity to make a difference?


Young Leaders, literally flying the flag